The Right to Identity: Adoptee Access Under Kentucky Law

Blog Post | 115 KY. L. J. ONLINE | November 16, 2026

The Right to Identity: Expanding Adoptee Access Under Kentucky Law

By: Lily Derthick, Staff Editor, Vol. 115 

An original birth certificate is more than an administrative record. Its contents, which typically include “the names of the birth parents, the date and place of birth, and the name given to the child at birth,” may seem mundane.[1] For adoptees, however, this information can provide a link to information often obscured by adoption: their medical history and sense of identity. Despite the significance of this information, many adoptees face substantial legal barriers to accessing their own original birth certificates.[2]

In thirty-three states, adoptees do not have “the right to request and obtain a copy of their own original birth certificates.”[3] Kentucky is one such state, requiring that its Cabinet for Families and Children perform “a search for the biological parents to ascertain whether they consent to the inspection.”[4] Even when an adoptee’s biological parents are deceased, a court “may order the inspection,” thus leaving the decision to judicial discretion.[5] This convoluted process also imposes fees, and it does not guarantee that an adoptee will ultimately gain access to their original birth certificate.[6]

Even when a Kentucky adoptee successfully navigates this process, the outcome may still be inadequate. The amended birth certificate provided to an adoptee substitutes original information to reflect the adoptive placement, including “the residence of the adoptive parents as the birthplace of the child.”[7] Such substitutions can forever obscure the information adoptees seek to recover and reinforce the legal fiction that an adoptee’s identity begins anew with adoption. The disparity is particularly striking when noting that “[i]f you are not adopted, your original birth certificate . . . is always available to you upon request.”[8]

Because an adoptee often cannot obtain an oral history of their biological medical history due to a lack of contact with their biological family, having no original birth certificate can pose significant obstacles to obtaining proper medical care. Without a biological medical history, adoptees “may face unnecessary medical testing, delayed diagnoses, or challenges in accessing appropriate services.”[9] This information can be critical for diseases with hereditary links that can be fatal, such as breast cancer.[10] Moreover, identity-related trauma specific to the adoption experience may contribute to the heightened risk of psychological struggles among adoptees—for example, “a fourfold increase in suicide risk.”[11] Thus, access to original birth certificates may provide information essential to understanding inherited medical risks and lessening adoptees’ mental health risks.[12]

There has been a trend among states to ease the procedural burden on adoptees’ access to their original birth certificate.[13] This is a positive development so long as it simultaneously considers the rationale for restrictive adoptee access laws: maintaining the anonymity of biological and adoptive parents.[14] An applicable Virginia state law amended this year has effectively struck this balance.[15] Now, in Virginia, “the State Registrar shall provide an adult adopted person access to his original birth certificate and contact preference form,” which indicates the biological parents’ contact preferences.[16]

A 2024 amendment to KRS § 199.572 suggests that the Kentucky legislature may be prepared to strike a similar balance between adoptee access and parental privacy.[17] The amendment established a process through which certain adult relatives of a deceased biological parent or a deceased adoptee may petition the court for authorization to inspect sealed adoption records.[18] Although the statute leaves authorization to the court’s discretion, this amendment nevertheless represents a meaningful expansion of adoptee access rights in Kentucky.[19]

Despite this progress, Kentucky law continues to restrict adoptees’ access to their original birth certificates by permitting the issuance of amended birth certificates and affording courts and biological parents substantial discretion.[20] The nationwide trend toward expanding adoptee access, alongside Kentucky’s 2024 amendment, presents an opportunity to reconsider whether Kentucky’s existing framework adequately protects adoptees’ interests.[21] By examining the approaches adopted by other states, such as Virginia, Kentucky lawmakers should develop legislation that grants adult adoptees the presumptive right to obtain their original birth certificates while preserving a mechanism for biological parents to communicate their contact preferences.


[1] Understanding Original Birth Certificates (OBC): A Guide for Adoptees, DiscoverFamily.net (Oct. 16, 2024), https://www.discoverfamily.net/original-birth-certificate-adoptees/.

[2] See Gregory D. Luce, The United States of OBC, Adoptee Rts L. Ctr (July 1, 2026), https://adopteerightslaw.com/united-states-obc/.

[3] See id.

[4] Belden v. Cabinet for Families & Childr., 488 S.W.3d 45, 46 (Ky. Ct. App. 2016).

[5] Id. (emphasis added).

[6] Birth Certificates, Cabinet for Health and Fam. Servs.: Vital Stats. Branch (2026),  https://www.chfs.ky.gov/agencies/dph/dehp/vsb/Pages/birth-certificates.aspx (explaining “[t]he fee covers the cost of the search and is non-refundable if a certificate is not found”).

[7] Ky. Rev. Stat. Ann. § 199.570 (LexisNexis 2024); Understanding Original Birth Certificates (OBC): A Guide for Adoptees, supra note 1 (describing “[f]or adoptees, the OBC is often replaced by an Amended Birth Certificate (ABC) after the adoption is finalized”).

[8] Luce, supra note 2.

[9] Donald Cofsky, Navigating an Adopted Child’s Incomplete Medical History, Cofsky & Zeidman (Nov. 12, 2025), https://www.209law.com/navigating-an-adopted-childs-incomplete-medical-history/.

[10] Adoptees Lacking Family Health History Look to Whole Genome Sequencing for Answers, HudsonAlpha Inst. for Biotech. (Oct. 16, 2018), https://www.hudsonalpha.org/adoptees-lacking-family-health-history-look-to-whole-genome-sequencing-for-answers/ (recounting the story of “a family mourning the loss of their adopted daughter, Niki, who suffered a number of symptoms that would have been diagnosed as breast cancer were she not 25 without family medical history”).

[11] Understanding Adoption Trauma: Signs, Effects, and Healing Strategies, Pac. Neurocounseling (July 4, 2025), https://seattleneurocounseling.com/blog-1/understanding-adoption-trauma-signs-effects-and-healing-strategies.

[12] See Cofsky, supra note 9; Debbie Wynne, Putting the Pieces Together: The Significance of the Child’s Story, Nat’l Council for Adoption (Dec. 1, 2017), https://adoptioncouncil.org/publications/adoption-advocate-no-114/.

[13] See Luce, supra note 2.

[14] Wynne, supra note 11.

[15] See Va. Code Ann. § 63.2-1246 (LexisNexis 2026).

[16] Id.; Va. Code Ann. § 32.1-261 (LexisNexis 2026).

[17] Ky. Rev. Stat. Ann. § 199.572(3) (LexisNexis 2024).

[18] Id.

[19] Id. (stating “the court may . . . authorize the adult person to inspect the papers and records”) (emphasis added).

[20] Id. (requiring that biological parents consent before an adoptee may inspect adoption records); § 199.570 (proscribing procedures for the creation of an amended birth certificate post-adoption).

[21] § 199.572(3); see Luce, supra note 2.

Next
Next

Keeping the Faith: Kentucky Courts Should Adopt the “Pattern of Practice” Test When Evaluating If Religious Gifts Constitute Dissipation